Proof of false claims of stolen ideas by Elizabeth Doyle-Propst

Evidence in the stalking, slander, false charges filed, and perjury by Elizabeth Doyle-Propst of Breath of Hope, Inc.

Despite Elizabeth and Stacy's claims that CHERUBS "steals" their ideas, you can see how they had only 1 original idea at Breath of Hope and how CHERUBS did / talked about everything else long before Breath of Hope did. Everything is documented. All their accusations are false and attempts to try to hurt CHERUBS. Why would a person or organization want to claim stakes to ideas or phrases if their intentions truly were only to help others - especially when they aren't even theres?

You can click on the items on CHERUBS side of this list to view more information. Click on the Breath of Hope side to see how CHERUBS did / said it first - and therefore Elizabeth, Stacy and Breath of Hope cannot claim it as their own.

Please remember that CHERUBS did not have any other group to imitate, no group to recruite from, no internet when we started - unlike Breath of Hope. And we have no problem with Breath of Hope doing the same things we are doing - however, we do have a problem with them claiming that we stole ideas from them.

CHERUBS	YEAR	Breath of Hope
CHERUBS is founded CHERUBS is granted an EIN and 501 (c) III Non-Profit Status CHERUBS Board of Directors is formed Our first issue of our quarterly newsletter, The Silver Lining CHERUBS Parent Reference Guide was created	1995
First newspaper article about CHERUBS is printed CHERUBS attend our first APSA conference in San Diego, CA	1996
CHERUBS first Congenital Diaphragmatic Hernia Research Survey Results CHERUBS New Member Packets CHERUBS goes on-line CHERUBS web site is created CHERUBS first listserv is started CHERUBS Prayer List is created	1997
We have our first Secretary, volunteer Judi Toth, mom of Christopher Toth CHERUBS Volunteer Coordinator position is created Congenital Diaphragmatic Hernia Research Survey Results are published International & State Representatives are created Cooking with Cherubs is published CHERUBS 1999 Calendars are published CHERUBS first bake sale CHERUBS first raffle held CHERUBS first on-line chats CHERUBS membership grows to over 100 CDH families	1998
CHERUBS is contacted by ABC's 20/20 staff for input on a story of a cherub The term Congenital Diaphragmatic Hernia Awareness was first used at CHERUBS CHERUBS members participate in Noah's Flood ECMO Fundraiser for National Children's Hospital in Washington, DC Our first Grieving Parents Get-Together is held outside of Washington, DC Congenital Diaphragmatic Hernia Research Survey Results are published CHERUBS listservs move to Onelist.com, which becomes Yahoogroups A forum for CDH medical professionals is created New seperate listservs were created for grieving parents and parents of survivors CHERUBS Advisory Committee is created CHERUBS Conference Committee is created CHERUBS Kids Book Committee is created CHERUBS Fundraising Committee is created CHERUBS Research Committee is created CHERUBS Welcoming Committees are created CHERUBS Card Committees are created CHERUBS Grant Committee is Created CHERUBS Welcoming Committees are created CHERUBS Totebag Committee is created CHERUBS Library Committee is created CHERUBS offer parents free web site graphics CHERUBS 2000 Calendars are published CHERUBS first Lock-In Fundraiser CHERUBS first t-shirts and sweatshirts are created CHERUBS first Christmas Fairy fundraiser Newsletter Tribute fundraiser is started CHERUBS membership grows to over 500 CDH families	1999
Our first CHERUBS International Member Conference is held in Orlando, Florida Our first Australia National Member Get-together is held Our first Ohio member picnic is held in Columbus, OH Congenital Diaphragmatic Hernia Research Survey Results are published CHERUBS first message boards were created Cooking with Cherubs Volume II is published Our first Ebay Auctions are held Our first Celebrity Auction is held Listservs were created for our various Committees	2000
Family Circle magazine contacts CHERUBS for input on a story of a cherub CHERUBS petition for Certification of Ultrasound Technicians is started Our first North Carolina member get-together is held outside of Charlotte, NC Our first member Candlelighting Ceremony is held CHERUBS CDH Video Committee is formed CHERUBS Australia creates it's own national web site Australia National Member Get-together is held Ohio member picnic is held in Columbus, OH CHERUBS reaches 1000 members	2001
CHERUBS moves into it's first office Our first Alabama member get-together is held Our first Texas member get-together is held Our first United Kingdom National Member Get-together is held Australia National Member Get-together is held CHERUBS 2nd Celebrity Ebay Auction is held Ohio member picnic is held in Columbus, OH <>CHERUBS is contacted by Lifetime Televisions "Strong Medicine" for a CDH story line <>CHERUBS membership grows to over 1000 CDH families	2002
Member Ebay Auction fundraiser is held Australia National Member Get-together is held United Kingdom National Member Get-together is held Ohio member picnic is held in Columbus, OH	2003
CHERUBS UK is granted Non-Profit Status Heidi Cadwell represents CDH parents at the International CDH Study Group Congress in Texas CHERUBS Listservs were created for each state and country where we have members CHERUBS cafepress store is launched Australia National Member Get-together is held United Kingdom National Member Get-together is held Ohio member picnic is held in Columbus, OH CHERUBS 2005 Calendars are published Awareness bracelets are discussed but idea dismissed CHERUBS Adopt A Cherub Link Program was started as individual awareness tools	2004	Elizabeth is banned from CHERUBS CherubsRus Yahoo group created - name later changed to Breath of Hope, Inc ALL of BoH's members were recruited from CHERUBS
CHERUBS submits research data for inclusion in the International CDH Study Group Congress in Germany Ohio member picnic is held in Columbus, OH United Kingdom National Member Get-together is held Australia National Member Get-together is held CHERUBS membership grows to over 1500 CDH families	2005	Seperate listservs created
"Stories of Cherubs" is published CHERUBS new web site is started Ohio member picnic is held in Columbus, OH Australia National Member Get-together is held United Kingdom National Member Get-together is held	2006	Prayer list created BoH claims to own the idea to "photos of cherubs together" as a "masthead" - though Stacy says in the next sentence that "all other organizations do this"
With several other support groups, CHERUBS joins the Alliance of Congenital Diaphragmatic Hernia Organizations CHERUBS Australia files for Non-Profit Status CHERUBS Board of Directors welcomes 3 new members Angels for CHERUBS is started CHERUBS New Member Coordinator position is created CHERUBS new web site goes live CHERUBS offers parents personal photo albums on-line CHERUBS offers parents personal web blogs CHERUBS offers dads their own forum CHERUBS offers grandparents their own forum CHERUBS Angel Ball Committee is formed CHERUBS Golf Tournament planning begins Ohio member picnic is held in Columbus, OH Australia National Member Get-together is held United Kingdom National Member Get-together is held Michigan get-together is held in Flint, MI CHERUBS Posting Contest Started ATV Rally Planned CDH / NICU Baby Book Committee formed Trick-or-Treat for CHERUBS Fundraiser started CHERUBS begins affiliate relationship with GoodSearch.com First Congenital Diaphragmatic Hernia Information Packet Party held Dawn has to file a restraining order against a former member CHERUBS undergoes an NC State Department audit and investigation and passes with flying colors Congenital Diaphragmatic Hernia Awareness Ribbon Created Congenital Diaphragmatic Hernia Awareness Jewelry designing begins CDH Awareness Logo created CDH Awareness Ribbon Car Magnets created CHERUBS Myspace Page created CHERUBS Facebook Page created CHERUBS Blogger Account created CHERUBS Live Space created CHERUBS on MDJunction.com CHERUBS on JustGiving.org CHERUBS on Guidestar.org CHERUBS Car Wash is held CHERUBS Truffle Sale is held CHERUBS is listed with Wikipedia Children's Holiday Card Drawing Contest Christmas Raffle Idea begun Donation Jar Idea begun Christmas Fundraising Posters for Stores Idea begun Valentine's Day Fundraising Posters for Stores Idea begun CDH Awareness Postage Stamps Idea begun Christmas Card Donations Idea begun Personalized Graphics for CDH Awareness Big Y Community Campaign begun 2007 Silver Lining Newsletter Free Downloadable CDH Awareness Address Labels created "Cherub On Board" Maternity Shirts created Construction of Congenital Diaphragmatic Hernia Research Site begun CHERUBS membership grows to over 2000 CDH families CHERUB Web Site averages 300,000 hits per MONTH	2007	Filed for and granted Non-Profit Status New Member Packets sent to parents Claim to first say "Congenital Diaphragmatic Hernia Awareness" Started Congenital Diaphragmatic Hernia Awareness Day Campaign - brag about copying Breast Cancer Awareness campaign - on March 31 (CDH Awareness Day) Elizabeth files a false complaint with the NC State Dept against CHERUBS to try to have CHERUBS shut down Website created First quarterly newsletter published Cafepress store created Calendars created Individual awareness graphics created CDH Awareness Postage Stamp created on Zazzle - just a matter of days after it was posted on CHERUBS site Claims to be the first to use statistics on how many CDH babies are born each year Claims to be the first to compare CDH to Spina Bifida and Cystic Fibrosis Consider Awareness Bracelets Create CDH Awareness Ribbon Donation jars discussed Donation posters discussed Myspace Profile - 6 months after CHERUBS Facebook Group - almost a yr after CHERUBS
CHERUBS name changed to CHERUBS - The Association of Congenital Diaphragmatic Hernia Research, Awareness and Support CHERUBS becomes Incorporated CDH Awareness Video 2008 International Member Conference Angel Ball Golf Tournament ATV Rally Bike Run CHERUBS on Zazzle.com CHERUBS Random Acts of Kindness Cards New CDH Logo For Teenagers Ohio Member Picnic Michigan Member Get-Together North Carolina Member Get-Together Grieving Parents Get-Together CHERUBS starts Firstgiving Campaign	In 2008	Breath of Hope starts Firstgiving Campaign - less than a week after it was posted at CHERUBS Create Facebook Cause - months after CHERUBS Sell Awareness Bracelets - 2 years after discussed on CHERUBS listservs